Alternatives
Best Buttercup alternatives in 2026
Data compiled by Toolradar Updated How we rate
Cite this list: Toolradar, best Buttercup alternatives 2026, toolradar.com/alternatives/buttercup
3 direct alternatives to Buttercup and 5 more tools in the same category, compared on pricing, features, and best-for use cases. Pick the right replacement without the marketing fluff.
Quick answer
- LastPass is the top alternative to Buttercup on our list, followed by CyberArk and Mullvad VPN.
- 2 of the 8 alternatives have a free plan, starting with LastPass.
- Highest rated: 1Password, 4.7 out of 5 from 3,945 ratings, Sep 2026.
- 8 alternatives
- 3 direct
- 2 with a free plan
Top 3 alternatives to Buttercup
LastPass
#1 Top pickSecurely store, autofill, and share passwords across all your devices
Starting price
From $3 /mo
Cheapest paid plan, monthly, as of October 2026
4.6 /5 across G2 and Capterra · 4,877 ratings, Sep 2026
Our take
Best overall
CyberArk
#2Secure every identity across human, machine, and AI with intelligent privilege controls.
Pricing
Contact sales
3.8 /5 across Trustpilot, G2 and Capterra · 976 ratings, Sep 2026
Mullvad VPN
#3Anonymous VPN with no personal info required
Starting price
From $5 /mo
Cheapest paid plan, monthly, as of October 2026
3.7 /5 across G2, SourceForge and Trustpilot · 154 ratings, Aug 2026
Buttercup vs 8 alternatives
| Tool | Starting price (Oct 2026) | Free plan | Rating | Fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Price: Free + paid | Free plan: Yes | 3.3 out of 5, from 9 ratings across G2 and SourceForge (9) | |
| Price: $3/mo | Free plan: Yes | 4.6 out of 5, from 4,877 ratings across G2 and Capterra (4,877) | Direct alternative |
| Price: Contact sales | Free plan: No | 3.8 out of 5, from 976 ratings across Trustpilot, G2 and Capterra (976) | Direct alternative |
| Price: $5/mo | Free plan: No | 3.7 out of 5, from 154 ratings across G2, SourceForge and Trustpilot (154) | Direct alternative |
 | Price: Contact sales | Free plan: No | 4.5 out of 5, from 2,341 ratings across G2 and Capterra (2,341) | Same category as Buttercup |
 | Price: $3.49/mo | Free plan: No | 4.0 out of 5, from 18,319 ratings across G2, Capterra, SourceForge and more (18,319) | Same category as Buttercup |
 | Price: $3.99/mo | Free plan: No | 4.7 out of 5, from 3,945 ratings across G2 and Capterra (3,945) | Same category as Buttercup |
 | Price: $1.5/mo | Free plan: No | 4.7 out of 5, from 3,747 ratings on G2 (3,747) | Same category as Buttercup |
 | Price: Free + paid | Free plan: Yes | 4.4 out of 5, from 12,494 ratings across G2 and Capterra (12,494) | Same category as Buttercup |
Why people consider alternatives to Buttercup
Buttercup is a free and open-source password manager designed to help users securely store and manage their login credentials.
Teams most often switch away when one of these starts to bite:
- Pricing at scale as usage or premium tiers add up.
- Missing integrations with the rest of your stack.
- Performance or scale limits as your needs grow.
- A specific feature gap you have hit in security.
The 3 direct alternatives below cover the same core job (security) with different trade-offs. The 5 tools marked "Same category as Buttercup" fit the category but replace Buttercup less directly.
Security leaderboards from Toolradar data
Toolradar ranks Security tools on one measure at a time, only where at least 8 tools have data. As of Nov 2026.
Lowest entry price, plans with no stated unit
Cheapest standard paid plan per month (annual prices divided by 12), read on vendor pages and compared only with tools priced on the same basis.
Counted among 171 tools with no stated price unit, verified price.
| # | Tool | Entry plan |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | HashiCorp Vault | $0.50/mo, billed monthly |
| 2 | Runbox | $0.66/mo, billed yearly |
| 3 | uTerminal | $0.83/mo, billed yearly |
| 4 | Alive | $0.99/mo, billed monthly |
| 5 | Addy.io | $1/mo, billed yearly |
Lowest entry price, per-user plans
Cheapest standard paid plan per month (annual prices divided by 12), read on vendor pages and compared only with tools priced on the same basis.
Counted among 40 tools priced per user, verified price.
| # | Tool | Entry plan |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Zoho Mail | $1/user/mo, billed monthly |
| 2 | AccessOwl | $1.50/user/mo, billed monthly |
| 3 | Corma | $3/user/mo, billed monthly |
| 3 | Duo Security | $3/user/mo, billed monthly |
| 3 | Fastmail | $3/user/mo, billed monthly |
Lowest entry price, flat team plans
Cheapest standard paid plan per month (annual prices divided by 12), read on vendor pages and compared only with tools priced on the same basis.
Counted among 15 tools priced as a flat team plan, verified price.
| # | Tool | Entry plan |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hide.me | $2.50/mo flat, billed monthly |
| 2 | 1Password | $3.99/mo flat, billed monthly |
| 3 | Malwarebytes | $5/mo flat, billed yearly |
| 4 | Sentaro | $6/mo flat, billed yearly |
| 5 | Avast | $6.50/mo flat, billed yearly |
Most visited, last 30 days
Distinct visitor sessions on the tool's Toolradar page over the last 30 days, with bots excluded by our analytics. A session counts once however many times it reloads the page.
Counted among 11 tools with 50+ visits.
| # | Tool | Visits |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Proton VPN | 1,427 visits |
| 2 | Hide.me | 834 visits |
| 3 | Windscribe VPN | 639 visits |
| 4 | Opera | 619 visits |
| 5 | ZoogVPN | 365 visits |
Most media coverage, last 30 days
Number of distinct articles published in the last 30 days by independent press, blogs and newsletters that mention the tool. A story carried by several outlets counts once; the vendor's own blog, review sites, forums and republishing sites do not count.
Counted among 33 tools mentioned in the last 30 days.
| # | Tool | Articles |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | ServiceNow | 21 articles |
| 2 | GitLab | 13 articles |
| 3 | ConnectWise | 12 articles |
| 4 | BitGo | 9 articles |
| 5 | Harmonic Security | 5 articles |
A position exists only when at least 8 tools have data for that metric. 234 of 735 Security tools have a verified price; the others publish none we could read (often "contact sales"). Advertising and placement fees are not inputs to any position. Visit counts include visits from every source. How we compute this. Cite this: Toolradar, “Security leaderboards”, Nov 2026. Data licensed CC BY 4.0. All Security statistics.
8 alternatives to Buttercup
Direct alternatives come first, ranked by G2 and Capterra ratings, media mentions, and editor review. Tools marked "Same category as Buttercup" follow, ranked the same way.
- 1
LastPass
Free plan Higher rated by usersSecurely store, autofill, and share passwords across all your devices
4.6 /5 across G2 and Capterra · 4,877 ratings, Sep 2026
From $3/mo, billed monthly; free plan available
- 2
CyberArk
Paid Higher rated by usersSecure every identity across human, machine, and AI with intelligent privilege controls.
3.8 /5 across Trustpilot, G2 and Capterra · 976 ratings, Sep 2026
Price not published
- 3
Mullvad VPN
Paid Higher rated by usersAnonymous VPN with no personal info required
3.7 /5 across G2, SourceForge and Trustpilot · 154 ratings, Aug 2026
From $5/mo, billed monthly
- 4
ServiceNow
Paid Higher rated by usersDigitize and automate workflows for IT, HR, and customer service
4.5 /5 across G2 and Capterra · 2,341 ratings, Sep 2026
Price not published
Same category as Buttercup
- 5
NordVPN
Paid Higher rated by usersOnline VPN service for privacy
4.0 /5 across G2, Capterra, SourceForge and more · 18,319 ratings, Sep 2026
From $3.49/mo, billed monthly
Same category as Buttercup
- 6
1Password
Paid Higher rated by usersSecurely store passwords, cards, and docs with end-to-end encryption
4.7 /5 across G2 and Capterra · 3,945 ratings, Sep 2026
From $3.99/mo flat, billed monthly
Same category as Buttercup
- 7
NinjaOne
Paid Higher rated by usersThe easiest IT management platform for unified endpoint management and IT operations.
4.7 /5 on G2 · 3,747 ratings, Mar 2026
From $1.50/endpoint/mo, billed monthly
Same category as Buttercup
- 8
IBM Cloud
Free plan Higher rated by usersEnterprise cloud platform by IBM
4.4 /5 across G2 and Capterra · 12,494 ratings, Sep 2026
Free plan available; paid prices not published
Same category as Buttercup
Frequently asked questions
What is the best alternative to Buttercup?
Based on real-signal scoring (G2 and Capterra ratings, media mentions, and editorial review), the top alternatives to Buttercup are LastPass, CyberArk, Mullvad VPN. Each solves the same core job with different trade-offs on pricing, features, and integrations.
Is there a free alternative to Buttercup?
There is no fully free alternative in this list. LastPass is freemium: a permanent free tier plus paid plans (Securely store, autofill, and share passwords across all your devices).
Why do people look for Buttercup alternatives?
Common reasons teams switch away from Buttercup: pricing that scales aggressively, missing integrations with the rest of their stack, performance or scale limits, or a specific feature gap in security. The alternatives on this page solve the same core problem with different trade-offs.
Side-by-side comparisons
In-depth comparison pages for Buttercup versus each alternative.
Review Buttercup, get a free AI guide
Share your experience and we will send you Improve Your Thinking Patterns Using ChatGPT, free.
Still considering Buttercup?
See the full review, pricing breakdown, and community feedback before you decide.