Skip to content

Merchant of Record Fees Compared (2026): Paddle, Polar, Lemon Squeezy and More

TL;DR

Creem has the lowest merchant of record fees for a small SaaS: 3.9% + 40¢ per transaction, $235 a month at $5k MRR in our scenario. From $50k MRR, Polar's paid plans win: Growth costs $2,250 a month there, and Scale costs $10,400 at $250k. Paddle charges 5% + 50¢ with no surcharges, while Lemon Squeezy adds 0.5% on subscription payments.

Eight merchants of record priced on the same SaaS revenue at three sizes, with surcharges, payout fees and tax coverage.

Updated
Publications that cover the tools tracked here
  • TechCrunch
  • Bloomberg
  • The Information
  • Fortune
  • The Verge
195 Payment Processing tools tracked
Polar brand card, the merchant of record with the lowest bill at scale in this comparison

A merchant of record (MoR) sells your software in its own name, so it collects and remits sales tax and VAT, handles disputes and carries the compliance work. You pay for that in the fee, and the gap between providers is wider than the headline rates suggest: on the same mid-size revenue in our scenario, the bills in this guide run from $2,250 to $5,500. Our view is that a SaaS founder should compare the fee at their real revenue and card mix, because the cheapest provider changes as you grow.

Toolradar data: our payment processing category tracks 195 tools, and 31% list a free or freemium plan, which for payment tools usually means pay-per-transaction with no monthly fee. Only a handful of them act as merchant of record; the rest, like a standard payment gateway, leave tax registration and filing to you. The payment processing statistics cover the full category.

Methodology: we compared eight merchant-of-record products, chosen from the 195 payment tools we track, on the fees and surcharges printed on their pricing pages and fee documentation, all checked October 28, 2026. For non-MoR options, see our payment gateways guide.

Top Picks

Selected by comparing the fees each merchant of record publishes, the surcharges in its fee documentation and the tax compliance it states it covers. How we rate

Polar logo

Polar

#1 Top pick

An open-source merchant of record for developers with public tiered rates that drop as revenue grows.

Starting price

5% + 50¢; paid plans from $20/mo

Best for

SaaS and developer tools with steady revenue, mostly on US cards.

Creem logo

Creem

#2

A merchant of record with one low flat rate, no monthly fee and no international card surcharge.

Starting price

3.9% + 40¢, no monthly fee

Best for

Early-stage SaaS and AI products with global customers and modest revenue.

Paddle logo

Paddle

#3

The established SaaS merchant of record with one all-in rate and custom pricing at volume.

Starting price

5% + 50¢ per transaction

4.5 (239 reviews)

Best for

SaaS companies that want predictable fees and a long-standing provider.

Merchant of Record Fees Compared (2026): Paddle, Polar, Lemon Squeezy and More compared: starting price, rating and best use, as of November 2026. Each rating is the average of the review sites listed on that tool's card, weighted by the logarithm of their review counts.
Tool Starting price Rating Best for
Polar 5% + 50¢; paid plans from $20/mo n/a SaaS and developer tools with steady revenue, mostly on US cards.
Creem 3.9% + 40¢, no monthly fee n/a Early-stage SaaS and AI products with global customers and modest revenue.
Paddle 5% + 50¢ per transaction 4.5 239 reviews SaaS companies that want predictable fees and a long-standing provider.
Lemon Squeezy 5% + 50¢ plus surcharges 1.2 154 reviews Indie makers selling digital products and small subscriptions.
FastSpring Custom quote 4.4 224 reviews B2B software companies that sell through quotes and invoices as well as checkout.
Stripe Managed Payments Check the current price on Stripe's site 4.4 3,839 reviews Teams already on Stripe that want merchant of record coverage without leaving it.
Gumroad 10% + 50¢ direct; 30% via Discover 2.3 350 reviews Creators selling ebooks, courses and memberships who value a simple storefront.
Payhip Check the current price on Payhip's site 4.7 10 reviews Creators selling mainly to US buyers who want US sales tax handled.
1
Polar logo
Top Pick

Polar

An open-source merchant of record for developers with public tiered rates that drop as revenue grows.

Starting price
5% + 50¢; paid plans from $20/mo
Free plan
No

Best for: SaaS and developer tools with steady revenue, mostly on US cards.

  • Pro: Scale plan cuts the rate to 3.4% + 30¢ for $400 a month, the lowest bill here in our largest scenario.
  • Pro: Publishes plan breakevens, so you can see exactly when to upgrade.
  • Pro: Usage billing, seats, credits and trials are listed as built-in features.
  • Con: Non-US cards add 1.5% on every plan, and Stripe payout fees are passed through.
  • Con: Disputes cost $15 each regardless of outcome.
Good value

Polar's "Per Transaction" pricing at 4% + 40¢ per transaction is on the higher side compared to some payment processors, but the inclusion of a Global Merchant of Record and negotiated volume discounts adds significant value.

Polar screenshot
Used Polar? Rate it
2
Creem logo

Creem

A merchant of record with one low flat rate, no monthly fee and no international card surcharge.

Starting price
3.9% + 40¢, no monthly fee
Free plan
No

Best for: Early-stage SaaS and AI products with global customers and modest revenue.

  • Pro: 3.9% + 40¢ is the lowest flat published rate in this guide.
  • Pro: No international card fees, so global revenue costs the same as US revenue.
  • Pro: Handles VAT, GST and sales tax in 50+ countries, with revenue splits to co-founders and affiliates.
  • Con: Payouts run only on the 1st and 15th of each month.
  • Con: At mid-size revenue on US cards, Polar's paid plans cost less.
Fair value

The Pay-as-you-go tier has no monthly fees, making it fair for low-volume or experimental projects, but high-volume merchants will feel the cost.

Watch out

No mention of minimum monthly volume; high fees punish low-ticket sales

Used Creem? Rate it
3
Paddle logo

Paddle

The established SaaS merchant of record with one all-in rate and custom pricing at volume.

  • 4.5 on G2 (239 reviews)
Starting price
5% + 50¢ per transaction
Free plan
No
Rating
4.5 (239 reviews)

Best for: SaaS companies that want predictable fees and a long-standing provider.

  • Pro: No monthly, migration or hidden fees listed on top of 5% + 50¢.
  • Pro: Covers tax, fraud protection, chargebacks and buyer support in the rate.
  • Pro: Custom pricing for high-volume and low-value transaction businesses.
  • Con: In our largest scenario, the standard rate costs about 44% more than Polar Scale.
  • Con: Custom rates require a sales conversation, so the real price at scale is not public.
Good value

Paddle's Starter tier at 5% + 50¢ per transaction is on the higher side for payment processing, especially compared to direct payment gateways.

Used Paddle? Rate it
4
Lemon Squeezy logo

Lemon Squeezy

A creator-friendly merchant of record, owned by Stripe, with storefronts, license keys and email marketing.

Starting price
5% + 50¢ plus surcharges
Free plan
No
Rating
1.2 (154 reviews)

Best for: Indie makers selling digital products and small subscriptions.

  • Pro: Free to start with storefront, license keys and affiliate tools included.
  • Pro: Email marketing is free up to 500 subscribers.
  • Pro: Payouts to US bank accounts via Stripe are free.
  • Con: Subscription payments add 0.5%, non-US transactions 1.5% and PayPal 1.5%.
  • Con: Its team is now focused on Stripe Managed Payments, and its CEO acknowledged slower support in January 2026.
Good value

Lemon Squeezy's eCommerce tier is fair, with a competitive 5% + 50c per transaction, especially considering the included tax compliance and fraud protection.

Used Lemon Squeezy? Rate it
5
FastSpring logo

FastSpring

A merchant of record for software and SaaS with B2B quotes and invoicing, priced by quote.

  • 4.5 on G2 (187 reviews)
  • 4.2 on Capterra (37 reviews)
Starting price
Custom quote
Free plan
No
Rating
4.4 (224 reviews)

Best for: B2B software companies that sell through quotes and invoices as well as checkout.

  • Pro: Collects and remits VAT and sales taxes on your behalf.
  • Pro: Interactive B2B quotes and digital invoicing are part of the platform.
  • Pro: Discounted rates for ACH and wire transfer transactions.
  • Con: Publishes no list rate; you submit volume, transactions and regional mix for a quote.
  • Con: Not a fit if you want to compare fees before talking to sales.
Fair value

FastSpring is a merchant of record (MoR) that bundles payment processing, global tax compliance, subscription billing, and fraud prevention into a single revenue-sharing fee.

Watch out

Payout schedule is twice monthly (15th and end of month). New accounts face a 45-day hold on initial payouts before any funds are released.

Used FastSpring? Rate it
6
Stripe Managed Payments logo

Stripe Managed Payments

Stripe's own merchant of record option, enabled inside Stripe Checkout and Payment Links.

  • 4.6 on Capterra (3,381 reviews)
  • 4.2 on G2 (458 reviews)
Starting price
Check the current price on Stripe's site
Free plan
No
Rating
4.4 (3,839 reviews)

Best for: Teams already on Stripe that want merchant of record coverage without leaving it.

  • Pro: Handles sales tax, VAT and GST in more than 80 countries.
  • Pro: Works with Checkout and Payment Links, including subscriptions.
  • Pro: Stripe covers the evidence submission fee when it counters a dispute for you.
  • Con: Does not support Stripe Connect or subscriptions created outside Checkout or Payment Links.
  • Con: Customers see purchases as sold through Link, and a dispute received fee applies.
Good value

Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction is the standard every payment processor is compared against.

Watch out

International card surcharge: +1.5% on top of the 2.9% base rate for cards issued outside your country. A US business charging a UK customer pays 4.4% + 30¢, not 2.9%

Stripe Managed Payments screenshot
Used Stripe Managed Payments? Rate it
7
Gumroad logo

Gumroad

A creator storefront that became a merchant of record in 2025, with a higher flat rate.

Starting price
10% + 50¢ direct; 30% via Discover
Rating
2.3 (350 reviews)

Best for: Creators selling ebooks, courses and memberships who value a simple storefront.

  • Pro: No monthly charges; handles sales tax collection and remittance as merchant of record.
  • Pro: Supports memberships and SaaS subscriptions as well as one-off products.
  • Pro: Discover marketplace can bring new buyers.
  • Con: At 10% + 50¢, it costs about twice Paddle's rate on the same sales.
  • Con: Sales through Discover cost 30%.
Great value

Gumroad's pricing is incredibly generous, offering a free entry point with a commission-based model.

Watch out

30% commission for marketplace discovery sales

Used Gumroad? Rate it
8
Payhip logo

Payhip

A digital product storefront that handles US sales tax as a marketplace facilitator.

Starting price
Check the current price on Payhip's site
Free plan
Yes
Rating
4.7 (10 reviews)

Best for: Creators selling mainly to US buyers who want US sales tax handled.

  • Pro: Has collected and paid US sales tax on sellers' behalf since July 1, 2026.
  • Pro: Sells courses, memberships and digital downloads from one store.
  • Pro: Publishes separate help articles for EU VAT and Canada sales tax.
  • Con: Described as a US marketplace facilitator, which is narrower than a full merchant of record.
  • Con: Its transaction fee is not part of the scenario totals above, so price it on Payhip's site before switching.
Great value

Payhip's pricing is very generous, especially with its 'Free Forever' tier which only charges a 5% fee per sale.

Used Payhip? Rate it

Other Payment Processing tools worth considering

More published tools from our Payment Processing category, ordered by our category ranking. They are not part of the editorial picks above.

What a merchant of record fee covers

A merchant of record fee is a percentage plus a fixed amount per transaction that bundles card processing, tax collection and remittance, fraud screening and dispute handling. With a plain payment gateway you are the seller of record, so you register, collect and file taxes yourself in every jurisdiction where you owe them; the higher MoR fee buys that work back.

The headline rate is not the full fee. Lemon Squeezy's fee documentation adds 0.5% for subscription payments, 1.5% for transactions outside the US and 1.5% for PayPal. Polar adds 1.5% for non-US cards and passes through Stripe payout fees: $2 per month of active payouts plus 0.25% + $0.25 per payout. Creem states it charges no international card fees, and Paddle's pricing page says there are no monthly fees, migration fees or hidden extras on its 5% + 50¢ rate.

Tax coverage also differs. Stripe's Managed Payments handles sales tax, VAT and GST in more than 80 countries, Creem collects and remits in 50+ countries, and Gumroad collects in regions where it has tax obligations as merchant of record. Payhip, by contrast, describes itself as a US marketplace facilitator that has handled US sales tax since July 1, 2026: that covers US tax, not the full merchant-of-record package.

How much do merchant of record fees cost at $5k, $50k and $250k MRR?

Our scenario: a SaaS with an average charge of $50, so the three sizes below mean 100, 1,000 and 5,000 charges a month, all on US cards. The totals are our arithmetic on published rates read October 28, 2026, before payout fees, disputes and refunds.

Table
Provider and rate $5k MRR $50k MRR $250k MRR
Creem, 3.9% + 40¢ $235 $2,350 $11,750
Polar Pro, $20/mo + 3.8% + 40¢ $250 $2,320 $11,520
Polar Growth, $100/mo + 3.6% + 35¢ $315 $2,250 $10,850
Polar Scale, $400/mo + 3.4% + 30¢ $600 $2,400 $10,400
Polar Starter or Paddle, 5% + 50¢ $300 $3,000 $15,000
Lemon Squeezy subscriptions, 5.5% + 50¢ $325 $3,250 $16,250
Gumroad direct sales, 10% + 50¢ $550 $5,500 $27,500

The Polar breakevens explain the pattern. Polar says Pro beats Starter above about $1,379 a month in sales, Growth above about $5,634 and Scale above about $19,048, so a fixed monthly fee pays for itself quickly once revenue is steady. Creem stays cheapest only at the small end.

Card mix can flip the order. If half of a $50k MRR comes on non-US cards, Polar Growth adds 1.5% on $25k, or $375, for $2,625, while Creem stays at $2,350 because it charges no international card fee. Paddle's flat rate carries no listed surcharge, and at very high volume Paddle, Lemon Squeezy and Creem all offer custom pricing.

Key Features to Look For

  • Rate structure (Essential)

    Compare percentage plus fixed fee at your average charge. A 50¢ fixed fee is 1% of the average charge in our scenario but 5% of a $10 one, so low-priced products feel the fixed part most.

  • Surcharges (Essential)

    Read the fee documentation, not only the pricing page. International cards, PayPal and subscription payments carry extra percentages at Lemon Squeezy, and non-US cards add 1.5% at Polar.

  • Tax coverage (Essential)

    Check which taxes the provider collects and remits, and where. A full merchant of record covers VAT, GST and US sales tax; a US marketplace facilitator covers US sales tax only.

  • Payout fees and timing (Important)

    Payout costs come on top of the transaction fee. Lemon Squeezy pays US bank accounts for free but charges 1% per payout outside the US, and Creem pays out on the 1st and 15th of each month.

  • Dispute costs (Important)

    Disputes are where hidden fees hide. Polar charges $15 per dispute regardless of outcome, and Stripe's Managed Payments charges a dispute received fee.

  • Subscription and usage billing (Important)

    SaaS sellers need trials, proration, seats or usage meters. Polar lists usage billing, seats and credits, and Creem lists usage-based billing, custom meters and credit wallets.

  • Migration path (Nice to have)

    Moving card-on-file subscribers between providers is the hardest part of switching. Ask how card data and active subscriptions move before you sign up.

What to check before choosing a merchant of record

  1. Model the fee at your actual average charge and monthly charge count, not at a round revenue number.

  2. Estimate the share of revenue from non-US cards and from PayPal, and add each provider's surcharges for that mix.

  3. List the countries where you have customers today and confirm the provider collects and files tax there.

  4. Ask whether custom pricing starts at your revenue level; Paddle, Lemon Squeezy, FastSpring and Creem all mention it.

  5. Read the dispute and payout terms, because a $15 dispute fee or a 1% payout fee changes the bill for small sellers.

Evaluation Checklist

  • Compute the monthly fee at your average charge, using the rate, the fixed fee and any monthly plan fee.

  • Add surcharges for subscriptions, non-US cards and PayPal from the fee documentation.

  • Add payout fees for your bank country and payout frequency.

  • Confirm the tax countries covered and whether the provider files returns, not only calculates tax.

  • Check dispute fees and who responds to disputes.

  • Ask how active subscriptions migrate in and out.

Pricing Overview

Low flat rate

Creem: one rate with no monthly fee and no international card surcharge, tax handled in 50+ countries.

3.9% + 40¢

Standard MoR rate

Paddle, Lemon Squeezy and Polar Starter: no monthly fee, with tax, fraud and disputes handled; surcharges vary.

5% + 50¢

Plan plus lower rate

Polar Pro, Growth and Scale: a fixed monthly fee in exchange for a variable rate down to 3.4% + 30¢.

$20 to $400/mo

Marketplace-style rate

Gumroad direct sales: creator tools and merchant of record coverage, with 30% on sales found through its Discover marketplace.

10% + 50¢

Quote-based

FastSpring, priced by volume, transactions and regional mix, and high-volume custom deals elsewhere.

Custom

Pricing Comparison

Merchant of Record Fees Compared (2026): Paddle, Polar, Lemon Squeezy and More pricing comparison, as of November 2026
Provider Published rate Extra fees in vendor docs Tax coverage stated

Polar

Starter 5% + 50¢; Pro, Growth, Scale $20 to $400/mo at 3.8% to 3.4%

+1.5% non-US cards; Stripe payout fees; $15 per dispute

International tax compliance as merchant of record

Creem

3.9% + 40¢, no monthly fee

No international card fees stated

VAT, GST and sales tax in 50+ countries

Paddle

5% + 50¢ per checkout transaction

No monthly, migration or hidden fees stated

Global tax compliance as merchant of record

5% + 50¢

+0.5% subscriptions; +1.5% non-US; +1.5% PayPal

Files and pays taxes as merchant of record

Custom quote

Discounted rates for ACH and wire

Collects and remits VAT and sales tax

Check the current price on Stripe's site

Dispute received fee applies

Sales tax, VAT and GST in 80+ countries

Gumroad

10% + 50¢ direct; 30% via Discover

No monthly charges

Sales tax collected where Gumroad has obligations

Payhip

Check the current price on Payhip's site

Not covered here

US sales tax as marketplace facilitator since July 1, 2026

Mistakes to Avoid

  • ×

    Comparing headline rates only, then discovering a 0.5% subscription surcharge or a 1.5% international card fee on most of your revenue.

  • ×

    Staying on a free starter rate long after a paid plan would cost less; Polar's Pro plan breaks even at about $1,379 a month in sales.

  • ×

    Assuming a marketplace facilitator covers VAT and GST abroad when it only covers US sales tax.

  • ×

    Ignoring payout fees, which can reach 1% per payout for bank accounts outside the US.

  • ×

    Choosing on fees alone and then finding the provider cannot migrate active subscriptions out.

Expert Tips

  • →

    Recompute your provider choice at each revenue milestone; on Polar the cheapest plan changes three times before monthly sales reach the Scale breakeven.

  • →

    Raise your average charge where you can: annual plans cut the number of fixed fees, which matters most on 40¢ to 50¢ per transaction.

  • →

    Weigh the two best-known options with our Lemon Squeezy vs Paddle comparison, and see FastSpring vs Paddle for B2B quote features.

  • →

    If you sell templates or courses rather than SaaS, our cheaper Gumroad alternatives guide compares creator platforms.

  • →

    Ask for custom pricing once monthly revenue is steady; Paddle, Lemon Squeezy and Creem all list a volume or partner route.

Red Flags to Watch For

  • Fee documentation that lists surcharges the pricing page does not mention.

  • A provider that cannot say which countries it files tax returns in.

  • A per-dispute fee with no published amount.

  • No documented way to export active subscriptions and customer data if you leave.

The Bottom Line

For most SaaS founders the cheapest merchant of record depends on revenue: Creem at 3.9% + 40¢ wins at a few thousand dollars a month, and Polar's Growth or Scale plan wins in our mid-size and large scenarios on mostly US cards. Paddle is the mature choice at 5% + 50¢ with no listed surcharges, which makes it easy to forecast. Lemon Squeezy costs more on subscriptions, and its team is now building Stripe's own merchant of record product, Managed Payments.

Gumroad suits creators who value its storefront more than its 10% rate, and FastSpring suits B2B software that needs quotes and invoices. For more context, see Paddle alternatives, Lemon Squeezy alternatives, the Gumroad vs Lemon Squeezy comparison and our subscription billing category.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which merchant of record has the lowest fees for SaaS?

At small volume, Creem's 3.9% + 40¢ is the lowest published rate: $235 a month in our smallest scenario of 100 charges a month on US cards. At the middle and largest sizes, Polar's Growth plan ($2,250) and then its Scale plan ($10,400) cost less. Prices were checked October 28, 2026.

How much does Paddle cost?

Paddle charges 5% + 50¢ per checkout transaction with no monthly, migration or hidden fees listed, and offers custom pricing for high-volume businesses. In our mid-size scenario of 1,000 charges a month, that is $3,000 a month by our arithmetic.

Are Lemon Squeezy's fees the same as Paddle's?

The headline rate is the same 5% + 50¢, but Lemon Squeezy's fee documentation adds 0.5% for subscription payments, 1.5% for non-US transactions and 1.5% for PayPal. For a subscription business on US cards, that makes Lemon Squeezy about 0.5 points more expensive than Paddle.

Is Lemon Squeezy still active after the Stripe acquisition?

Yes, its pricing page still sells checkout at 5% + 50¢. Stripe acquired Lemon Squeezy in 2024, and in a January 28, 2026 post its CEO said the team is building Stripe Managed Payments and plans an easy migration path for Lemon Squeezy users.

Is there a free merchant of record?

No provider here is free per sale, but most have no monthly fee: Creem, Paddle, Lemon Squeezy, Gumroad and Polar's Starter plan charge only per transaction. Polar's paid plans add a monthly fee from $20 in exchange for a lower rate.

When does a Polar paid plan pay off?

Polar publishes the breakevens against its Starter plan: about $1,379 a month in sales for Pro, $5,634 for Growth and $19,048 for Scale. Above each threshold the paid plan costs less than 5% + 50¢, before the 1.5% surcharge on non-US cards that applies to all plans.

Is Gumroad a merchant of record?

Yes. Gumroad has acted as merchant of record since January 1, 2025, collecting and remitting sales tax where it has obligations. It charges 10% + 50¢ on direct sales and 30% on sales that come through its Discover marketplace.

Cite this page: Toolradar, "Merchant of Record Fees Compared (2026): Paddle, Polar, Lemon Squeezy and More", updated October 2026, https://toolradar.com/guides/merchant-of-record-fees-compared

Spotted an outdated price or a wrong fact? Suggest a correction: we check it against the vendor's own page. Work for one of these vendors? Claim your listing to update it yourself.

Related Guides

Ready to Choose?

Compare features, read reviews, and find the right tool.

Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.